Miriam N.
5/18/2025
Yummy New York style pizza!!! Ordered a large mushroom pie. Great service from a new server. Will be back again!
New York City Pizza
$$
Closed
(90)
Photos
45 Pembroke Dr Ste 105
Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
Using only local, fresh, and simple ingredients since 1996, New York City Pizza is the best experience that gourmands can have on Hilton Head Island. From New York-style pizza to your favorite Italian dish, you can enjoy great pizza near you at our restaurant at 45 Pembroke Drive, Hilton Head Island, SC, or choose delivery or carryout. Our priority is to offer healthy food, so at New York City Pizza, you can indulge in our housemade, no preservatives pizza. Upon request, we can also offer gluten-free pizza and pasta. Hungry or craving? Visit us on Hilton Head Island or place an order online for takeaway, carryout, or home delivery.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.090 reviews
Michelle O.
8/19/2025
Came here to say after a 13 hr drive to HHI from Cleveland. Wanted something easy. Pizza was the consensus. Ordered 2 large. A pepperoni and cheese and a meat lovers. Cost $67. That's all we got...
Ja P.
4/26/2025
Just ok. Overpriced for how it turned out. Stromboli kind of bland. Chopped salad was mostly romaine lettuce. It had no olives as had been advertised. Pasta bolognese was pretty good. There are...
Yasmine A.
11/25/2024
I get this for takeout every time I'm on the island. My favorite is the Buffalo chicken sub! The pizza is good but has gotten expensive in recent years. The service is always fast for takeout,...
Jason S.
3/26/2024
Ordered NYCPC platter a long day of travel to HHI because it was close to our location and the menu looked good. Welp, it only did the menu look good; but the food looked great , and it tasted...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.