Paul D.
8/2/2025
Per Ryan Trahan, this placed had to be reviewed to see if all these bad reviews were true or not. 1. Roaches crawling around? zero 2. NYC Pizza authenticity? Yes, 15 plus years living in...
New York City Pizza
$
Closed
(371)
Photos
81 Pope Ave
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
Using only local, fresh, and simple ingredients since 1996, New York City Pizza is the best experience that gourmands can have on Hilton Head Island. From New York-style pizza to your favorite Italian dish, you can enjoy great pizza near you at our restaurant on 81 Pope Ave, Hilton Head Island, SC, or choose delivery or carryout. Our priority is to offer healthy food, so at New York City Pizza, you can indulge in our housemade, no preservatives pizza. Upon request, we can also offer gluten-free pizza and pasta. Hungry or craving? Visit us on Hilton Head Island or place an order online for takeaway, carryout, or home delivery.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0371 reviewsAnita M.
10/22/2025
What would I improve you ask ??? The service , as well as , the quality of the food ! Went in for a slice , was met with arrogance. Then decided to stay as ... ( hungry ) . Ordered pasta fagoli...
Ben T.
12/30/2024
We were down 2 weekends ago and had a slice of cheesecake from this place - it was highly recommended by the awesome associates Stephanie and Sarah. They didn't lie! It was the absolute best...
Eugene S.
8/30/2024
Hilton Head comes to a lull around 2pm and that's when everything eases away from both the lunch service as well as the sun so people are getting out of the heat and back to their homes or...
K S.
7/9/2025
ROACHES ROACHES ROACHES I would give zero stars if I could. We arrived around 7:30pm and waited 3-4 minutes before being greeted even though there were only two tables occupied and one person...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.