Ashley T.
10/4/2025
Every sandwich we've had here has been incredible. The bondi is our favorite. The lady who runs it is really kind and friendly. We waited over an hour on a busy Saturday and the sandwiches were...
Costello's Market
$$
Closed
(76)
Photos
99 Maple St Ste 13A
Middlebury, VT 05753
Costellos's Market in Middlebury, VT offers a delightful array of Italian deli items and fresh seafood at their charming location on Maple Street. With a focus on quality ingredients, they proudly feature braised lamb shanks in demi glaze and imported extra virgin olive oil from Tuscany and Sicily.
Customers can enjoy a diverse menu of lunch and dinner options, including daily specials and seafood delicacies. Known for their specialty meats and seafood catering services, Costellos's Market is a go-to destination for those seeking delicious and authentic Italian flavors.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.576 reviews
Michelle H.
12/3/2024
Delish! My husband and I came here for lunch during the weekend and it was the perfect meal to take and sit outside! Location/Decor 5/5: Loved the location of the store, it was perfectly placed...
Brian K.
9/27/2025
We went in here a couple of years ago during the pandemic and had an awful experience. Not only were none of the staff wearing masks, but we were mocked by the staff for wearing them ourselves....
Heather H.
4/4/2025
Exceptionally friendly, hometown shop. Offered fresh seafood and lots of sandwich and soup options. I love a good Rueben, and mine came out piping hot! Worth the wait.
Robert C.
8/29/2025
Food was good, service was excellent, but the prices are on the very high side for deli food. I ordered one large sub, a side salad and two drinks at a cost of $38.00!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.