Rustic Tavern

$
Closed
yelp logo

(206)

Call
Website

Photos

823 Newville Rd
Carlisle, PA 17013
+1 (717) 245-2999
https://rustictavern.com
Located in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, the Rustic Tavern is a successful mix of a casual atmosphere with the added touch of fine dining. Relax with friends and family by the fireplace or on the deck. Proprietors Tom (chef) and Penny Petsinis offer a wide variety of menu items utilizing local produce, meats and other products as well as weekly fresh seafood specials. In addition, the Rustic boasts a wide variety of wines and spirits. We look forward to providing you with a memorable dining experience, and remember “It’s all good!”

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0206 reviews
Photo of Susan W.
Susan W.
8/27/2025

Food was very good served hot and timely for our large group! Loved the servers. We had a large group of family as it was my 75th birthday.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Cindy B.
Cindy B.
8/1/2025

Food was great! Josie was our server and she is so pleasant and polite!!!! The American Flat bread was spectacular! I am so glad I have left overs. The Crab Melt Sandwich was delicious and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of John G.
John G.
8/2/2025

Terrific Dinner with wonderful family. The Rustic Tavern is very comfortable rustic! My BIL ordered a 14oz Delmonico Steak cooked perfectly med. topped with sautéed mushrooms and onions! My SIL...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Mercedes J.
Mercedes J.
7/10/2025

Service was great! Quick, polite, honest suggestions. Definitely appreciated it. Food was good but not the best. The crab cake was tasty by itself. On the sandwich, it needed more help than just...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of David W.
David W.
1/26/2025

Delicious busy tavern. I had scallops with fresh crab chunks on a bed of risotto. Garlic bread with cheese was also amazing

Read more on Yelp
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

Molly Pitcher Brewing Company
Bar (drinking places), Tavern (drinking places), Eating places

Molly Pitcher Brewing Company

117
•
$$
"Great food, solid brews, and awesome people. We had a fair share of grub and shared some flights of beer. Juicy double burgers on brioche - bbq bacon is solid with thick cut Smokey bacon. The..."
Caterers, Bar (drinking places), Tent and tarpaulin rental

Brick Kitchen and Bar

Brick Kitchen and Bar is a dining establishment located in Carlisle, PA, known for its inviting atmosphere and diverse culinary offerings. The restaurant aims to provide an enjoyable dining experience, though details about its specific menu and services are currently not accessible. Patrons can expect an environment that reflects a blend of warmth and comfort, making it a suitable choice for various occasions. Unfortunately, visitors may encounter technical issues when attempting to access additional information about the venue. Generated from the website
1794 The Whiskey Rebellion
Bars and lounges, Eating places, Steak restaurant

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

204
•
$$
"The food was good. The pretzel was a little chewy but the sauce made up for it. The Reuben and steak sandwich were both good. The old fashioned was extremely strong. The service was prompt and..."
photo of Laura W.
United States›Pennsylvania›Carlisle›Rustic Tavern

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Yext

Partial Data by Foursquare.