Dee B.
9/27/2025
Pie in the sky has the absolutely best pizza and subs! The staff is always so friendly.
Pie in the Sky
$$
Closed
(33)
Photos
105 Duncan St
Lancaster, PA 17602
Ever since Gennaro Lombardi opened his first pizzeria in New York in 1895, the love for pizza has grown into a $30 billion industry in the U.S. More than 3 billion of them are sold in U.S. restaurants every year, and that doesn't including frozen pizzas.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.033 reviews
Michele M.
5/19/2025
Pie in the Sky did the catering for my daughter's baby shower in May of 2025. From my 1st telephone call with the owner and the subsequent calls with the manager, the service was friendly,...
Donald L.
3/25/2025
This place has mastered the cheese steak and the Italian hoagie. The best local sandwich shop in Lancaster! Let's start with the toasted Amaroso carefully layered with thinly sliced meats, cheese,...
Audree S.
8/11/2024
The best pizza in lancaster Everything is excellent! The staff is friendly,treat you like family. Service is fast. It's my local pizza and sandwich shop-
Sam H.
10/8/2022
Mild wing sauce is terrible, nothing but grease no flavor. Would not get the wings. Also one of the wings had most of the meat missing.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.