Delicia H.
12/30/2017
We order from here a lot. We have never ever had a problem. The pizza is always great and the delivery is always in a timely manner. Super easy to order online too. Dont forget to tip your...
Plus 1 Pizza
$
Closed
(5)
Photos
26 Olive St
Caldwell, OH 43724
Plus 1 Pizza in Caldwell, Ohio prides itself on serving the best pizza within a 50-mile radius, guaranteeing fresh and exceptional ingredients in every bite. With a commitment to homemade dough, real Wisconsin cheese, and a variety of top-notch toppings, Plus 1 Pizza is the go-to spot for pizza lovers who refuse to settle for anything less than perfection.
By becoming a Plus One Rewards Member, customers can earn points for every dollar spent, unlocking exclusive member offers and the opportunity to earn free food with just 50 points. Whether ordering through their mobile app or in-store, Plus 1 Pizza ensures a delicious experience with their mouth-watering, made-to-order pizzas that have been voted the best in the area.
Generated from the website
Reviews
2.05 reviews
Sheryl S.
1/26/2020
If you are in Caldwell craving pizza, pick another place...this place has went downhill over the past few years. We ordered pizza at 5:40pm to be delivered off there online app, it said delivery...
Buddy N.
9/2/2017
Every time we are in town at the best western we try to order pizza while we are swimming but they always say it's 2 to 3 hours delivery time that's ridiculous
Ronda D.
3/30/2019
They have screwed my order up everytime! Manager is an idiot. After being a customer for 20 yrs will not order there again. Thank God for dominos!!
Jeff R.
9/17/2017
You cannot order a side of celery with wings online (even though it is on the menu AND you pay for it). Don't even think about ordering blue cheese dressing with your wings. They will not...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.