Ryan V.
7/23/2017
We found this place during a cross country road trip. Staying in Caldwell, we didn't have a lot of options and chose to drive through town to find this spot. The ladies working there were very...
Wally's Old Fashioned Pizza
$
Open
(22)
Photos
805 Miller St
Caldwell, OH 43724
Wally's Old Fashioned Pizza is a popular pizzeria located in Caldwell, OH, offering a wide selection of delicious pizzas made with traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients.
With additional locations in Cambridge, New Concord, and St. Clairsville, Wally's Old Fashioned Pizza has become a go-to destination for pizza lovers seeking authentic flavors and a nostalgic dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.522 reviews
Shan D.
7/26/2024
Pizza was yummy!! Service was excellent! No indoor seating, but weather was perfect for the outdoor seating area!
Father T.
5/30/2025
my pizza was medium rare....Crust was crisp, cheese melted, but the dough and toppings were barely cooked through.
Chandra F.
3/4/2024
My favorite pizza in our local area...always get it smothered in cheese, pepperoni and mushrooms
Cheryl S.
10/11/2019
Really, really good pizza. What a gem of a business located in charming Caldwell, OH. We ordered the thinner crust, which was crispy and flavorful with a hearty border. The sauce was hearty and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.