Gena W.
11/8/2025
So glad we live a couple mins away. We're new to Ohio and we're from Queens, NY. The pizza's pretty close to the real deal. Problem is it's not consistent from visit to visit. And don't understand...
Pizzeria New York
$
Open
(99)
Photos
833 Hill Rd N
Pickerington, OH 43147
Pizzeria New York is a cozy eatery in Pickerington, OH that specializes in serving a variety of pizzas and Italian dishes.
With a casual atmosphere and friendly service, this establishment offers a menu that caters to both dine-in and takeout customers.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
3.599 reviews
Kenny D.
3/10/2023
The big mistake I made all those years ago was driving past this place, assuming it wasn't designed for the normal family. That, mainly because the bar next door was always flooded with the rowdy...
William S.
3/7/2025
Outstanding pizza. I always judge a pizza place by the quality of their cheese pizza their cheese pizza was amazing. Really good work.
Collin S.
2/26/2025
Closest you'll get to NY pizza in cbus. Not you cheap value pizza night but the quality is good.
Patrick G.
9/13/2024
Best NY Pizza available love it to death Steeler fans as well!! But that's it
See a problem?
