Lori U.
6/28/2025
The food is fantastic, I have always received friendly service and the atmosphere can be whatever you want to make it.
Pizza Cottage - Pickerington
$$
Open
(108)
Photos
1000 Old Diley Rd
Pickerington, OH 43147
Pizza Cottage in Pickerington, Ohio, is a beloved pizza restaurant known for its delicious and authentic pizzas. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or looking to try something unique like a gourmet specialty pie, Pizza Cottage has got you covered. With an inviting atmosphere and friendly staff, this local favorite is the perfect spot for family dinners or casual gatherings with friends. At Pizza Cottage - Pickerington, we take pride in serving up mouthwatering pizzas made from fresh ingredients and topped with flavorful sauces and cheese. Our menu caters to all tastes with a variety of toppings to choose from, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy. Come experience the taste of tradition combined with modern flair at Pizza Cottage - your go-to destination for the best pizza in Pickerington, Ohio.
Reviews
3.5108 reviews
Steven E.
7/8/2024
Our first time here and we were very, very tired, we mistakenly thought we were stopping at the Cottage Inn for pizza. We quickly realized our mistake upon arrival. We did, however, find a...
Tramaine O.
10/29/2025
I go into the lobby and stand in line. After standing several minutes with no one approaching to help I go sit down and opt to call instead. I sit on hold for awhile and enjoy the view. Someone...
Tish Y.
12/1/2024
Delivery came quickly and pizza was hot. We were less thrilled with the very heavy toppings on a nice thin crust. Would love a better balance. Even the single topping pepperoni had way too much....
Mary B.
9/10/2022
This Pizza Cottage is located off Hill road and Refugee road in Pickerington. We stopped into this location after supporting a friend's son during the rivalry football game between North vs...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
