Pete R.
5/22/2025
Ordered a pizza on our way to the ferry. Not on the menu but they made us a Chicken Parmesan Pizza. Great coal fired crust, homemade sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese. The chicken was ok. Ate the...
The Pie
$$
Closed
(262)
Photos
216 Main St
Port Jefferson, NY 11777
The Pie is a family-owned restaurant in Port Jefferson, NY, renowned for serving authentic coal-fired Neapolitan pizza, making it a unique destination on Long Island. With a cozy atmosphere and a diverse menu featuring appetizers, fresh salads, homemade pastas, and desserts, it caters to both locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5262 reviews
Ari H.
9/5/2025
Came here curious, left disappointed. Margherita pizza: 8/10. Thin crust, sauce was nice, but no fresh basil... which is like forgetting the lime in a margarita. Buffalo pizza: not even worth the...
Marcella L.
7/12/2025
The Pie generally has a way of turning an ordinary appetizer into something special. Not so last night with the bruschetta. Was expecting crispy bread covered with vine ripened tomato. What we...
Kendra C.
2/20/2025
Nice early dinner cozy spot to eat! Fast service. Our waitress has such great energy and positive vibes it made the experience even better. Started to fill up once we started to leave around 6pm....
Philip D.
10/12/2025
One of the best tasting NY pepperoni and sausage pizzas and pear salad on the side combo we have had in Long Island!! Would highly recommend and would go back for this combo!
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
