Rita C.
9/22/2025
Great place for a quick bite to eat, especially after a night out. I've heard some things where their food wasn't great but I have never had any bad experiences with them! Love their chipotle...
Old Town Pizza
$
Open
(134)
Photos
691 Old Town Rd
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Welcome to Old Time Pizza, providing quality cuisine and service to Port Jefferson Station for over 25 years! Leave the cooking to us and “Buon Appetito
Reviews
3.0134 reviewsJeff S.
7/15/2025
Very good pizza. Perfect undercarriage. Just the right combination of sauce and cheese. This is one of the areas best pizza.
John M.
1/3/2025
Catered food last minute for my Dept. Just under 500 dollars we had about 70 people show up. Everyone loved the pork osso bucco with risotto. The risotto is unbelievable. Rigatoni Genovese what...
James D.
3/11/2024
Bad takeout. I did Uber eats that was good. But the food was terrible and just plain gross. The Buffalo cauliflower was mushy and the outside slimy. Right in the garbage. I got hot antipasto....
Stephanie S.
8/23/2024
This place has amazing salad pizza and pasta dishes. Love to grab take out or eat in this place. Have been ordering the salad pizza for years.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.