Heather W.
11/8/2025
Really delicious fresh, flavorful pizza; really friendly! Slices are on the thin side.
Sofia Pizza Shoppe
$
Open
(275)
Photos
989 1st Ave
New York, NY 10022
Sofia Pizza Shoppe is a classic, New York style pizzeria with a modern twist located in the Sutton Place community of Manhattan, NYC. Opened, owned, and operated by pizza aficionados Matthew Porter and Tom DeGrezia in 2016, we have partnered with local purveyors to acquire the finest quality ingredients and unique, premium toppings. Rooted in tradition, we have perfected the classics and also offer an array of distinctive original pies including our newest creation, The DoughDici™ . You won’t find added sugar in our sauces or dough and we are a nut-free facility. Each and every pie is a labor of love and our commitment to excellence is evident in every bite. We hope you enjoy!
Find related places
Reviews
4.5275 reviews
Rochelle N.
7/17/2025
Really good NY slices. Place is really small and only has one or two stools to eat but you could easily take this to the east river area and eat there. Service was super quick and two slices was...
Karishma A.
1/11/2025
**vegetarian review ** I think I saw someone on Reddit recommend this place so had it bookmarked for a while. I stopped by on a cold winter day craving hot food and boy did this place deliver....
Ami V.
11/4/2024
Truly amazing pizza, thickness wise id say it's thicker than your average ny slice but honestly at the end of the day I go for flavor and the flavor was there. I got a standard cheese There was...
Raylin T.
10/29/2025
Very good, perfect undercarriage , perfect pepperoni amount , and perfect price ..............
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.