Bill W.
7/17/2025
We walked past, and had to turn around to follow the aroma of NY pizza! We had a slice of meat-lovers... hot, crispy, cheery... delicious! The proprietor was friendly, asked us if this was our...
Port Jeff Pizza
$$
Open
(12)
Photos
124 Main St
Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Port Jeff Pizza, located in the heart of Port Jefferson, NY, offers a diverse menu featuring classic and specialty pizzas, calzones, and heroes, all crafted with high-quality ingredients. Their assortment also includes appetizers, salads, pastas, and delectable desserts, ensuring a satisfying meal for every taste.
With a focus on convenience, Port Jeff Pizza provides numerous deals and coupons to make dining affordable while maintaining a commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction. Whether craving a traditional cheese pizza or a more elaborate Buffalo Chicken Pizza, the eatery caters to both casual diners and pizza aficionados alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.512 reviewsGreg H.
7/18/2025
Went in there tonight ordered a slice of pizza for me and my wife. Man with curly hair charge almost $14 for a total of two slices paid cash. while eating our pizza the man charged three other...
Cary R.
4/13/2019
After stopping by many bars with Jay O. As we walked to the parking lot we made a stop here as we walked passed it. We decided just to try a slice and it was okay. They have many different types...
Sean C.
1/4/2023
I honestly don't understand how this place has a single negative review. The pizza is great, the staff is friendly, and they're open later than everyone else. If you're on the fence about giving...
Tyler H.
3/12/2021
Just ok. Meatball slice was fine. White Pie was sloppy. Wet on the bottom and slimy on top. If you stick with the tomato base pies you'll do fine.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.