Caleb W.
8/27/2025
First pizza place we went to in Fi-Di. Great location, vibes and the pizza is off the charts. Staff was nice and helpful. We got two pepperoni and a sausage and they were all amazing!
Underground Pizza
$
Closed
(370)
Photos
2 William St # 3
New York, NY 10004
Contact Underground Pizza at (646) 902-5793 in New York, NY, for quick pizza delivery service. Our Italian pizzeria offers mouthwatering pizza and calzones.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0370 reviews
Monique W.
9/1/2025
Wow! Some of the best New York City Pizza I've had is at Underground Pizza! I was hungry late Thursday evening around 8:00 after exploring the Financial District. Looking for nearby pizza places...
Aiai's W.
7/10/2025
Was charged extra. Ordered a 18.75$ pasta on the board, got charged 19$ + tax and customer charges, leading to 21.45$. The bathroom REEKED.
Kyle S.
7/30/2025
The food was average--not bad, not great. Service was friendly, but things took longer than expected. It's okay for a casual meal, but I wouldn't go out of my way.
Joe F.
12/30/2024
Authentic New York pizza experience, delicious slices. The owner Ben is the nicest guy, chatted us up and was appreciative that we thought the food looked good while strolling by and stopped in....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.