Emely F.
7/24/2025
Garlic Pizza NYC is a solid go-to! I grabbed a chicken Caesar slice and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crunchy, the flavors were on point, and they nailed the ratio of chicken,...
Garlic New York Pizza Bar
$
Closed
(516)
Photos
629 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10016
It starts with genuine, hand-tossed dough made from 100% Italian semolina wheat with no additive or preservatives. Next, the sauce. Vine-ripened tomatoes are hand-crushed, simmered and enhanced with a generations-old family recipe. Then, we add 100% pure, fresh mozzarella cheese that comes from a small local dairy farm.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5516 reviews
Caroline W.
10/21/2025
Pizza place we were in the area and decided to stop by It did the job and they did offer huge portions However wasn't crazy about the flavor and was definitely a bit too oily and greasy
Adam S.
12/12/2024
The food here is more so late night pizza due to the bar scene near by in Murray Hill. It's probably one of the better pizza spots in the area given its various options when it comes to square...
Melanie N.
2/19/2025
I ordered for delivery from this spot so I can't say much about ambiance or service. I could however share that the food was fresh great temperature the garlic pasta and shrimp I ordered was...
Jorge P.
1/22/2025
Great neighborhood pizza spot! Majority of their slices are flatbread style and they're all pretty great I would recommend the hot honey pepperoni, vodka slice, chicken caesar, and mushroom!...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.