Nagle's Bagels

$
Open
yelp logo

(185)

Photos

378 Tompkins Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11216

Reviews

yelp logo
3.0185 reviews
Photo of Destiny E.
Destiny E.
3/27/2025

There's honestly nothing very remarkable about this place. They are definitely a bit overpriced, and the bagels are smaller than they should be. Of course, it's obvious that you are paying for new...

Photo of Emily Y H.
Emily Y H.
2/23/2025

2nd time visiting our local bagel spot. Great when you are craving a heavy tasty bagel sandwich. We got the Nagles Sunrise with Jalapeño Chedder Bagel and The Gotham with whole wheat Everything...

Photo of Brenda R.
Brenda R.
10/8/2025

Toasted bagel with a tiny whisper of toast. Aren't we in NYC, the HOME of the bagel??! And isn't this a bagel shop above all else?

Photo of Janelle P.
Janelle P.
8/4/2024

This spot has a lot of negative reviews on here, so maybe I'm one of the lucky ones. We thought it was great for grabbing a quick breakfast bite. It's a small joint, so the service was a walk up...

Photo of Samantha C.
Samantha C.
11/3/2024

10/10 awesome bagels and a nice variety of delicious bagel sandwiches! Loved the Blue Velvet and the Veggie Nagle. Super cute spot - perfect for anyone strolling around the area and looking for...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkBrooklynNagle's Bagels

Partial Data by Foursquare.