My Pie

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(168)

Photos

166 W 72nd St
New York, NY 10023
Located in the heart of The Upper West Side, CityPie is the best source for the New York thin crust pizza experience.

Find related places

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5168 reviews
Photo of Asia C.
Asia C.
7/16/2021

Super cute place! I walked by this place while I was on break and I was starving so of course, I chose pizza. I asked the server which ones she recommended so I got the Artichoke and the Mushroom...

Photo of Nicholas G.
Nicholas G.
3/3/2021

Pizza in NYC is as famous as you can get. In this case it is roman style pizza which is these square type slices with all sorts ot toppings. I think they have a couple locations in nyc so looks...

Photo of Lucy M.
Lucy M.
5/15/2021

I love that this place is right by Riverside Park, it's easy to grab some slices and make a picnic fast. They do squares, and my favorite is their truffle mushroom slice. They don't over do it on...

Photo of Marc L.
Marc L.
3/8/2020

Not my favorite crust (it's square rather than round pie) but the toppings are amazing. Just tried the truffle mushroom - I think I'm on a truffle kick lately - and I'm in heaven. The options...

Photo of Mike S.
Mike S.
10/11/2020

Don't be alarmed by the 3 stars. Good pizza, not great. Crispy crust, flavor toppings. But it was missing something - the sauce just wasn't packing that kind of flavor I thought it would have....

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.