Patti F.
10/17/2025
10 out of 10!!! One of the best pizza places in upper Manhattan. This pizza is consistently award-winningly delicious! For me, I think the ambience is just spot on. It's exactly how I would...
Freddie & Pepper's
$
Closed
(566)
Photos
303 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10023
Founded in 1978, Freddie & Pepper's has established itself as a hallmark of pizza excellence in New York City, renowned for its unique flavors and commitment to quality. The dedicated team focuses on providing outstanding service and a delightful dining experience, ensuring every aspect from hygiene to ambiance is meticulously attended to.
Offering a diverse menu featuring traditional and innovative dishes, Freddie & Pepper's is particularly celebrated for its delicious pizza and empanadas. With a long-standing reputation for quality, this beloved establishment continues to attract patrons seeking a quintessential New York pizza experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0566 reviews
Emma M.
10/16/2025
I could vouch for Freddie and Pepper's being the best pizza in New York City. Every time I visit I am more than happy with my experience. The way that the cheese sits on the pizza and the way that...
Gold M.
8/16/2025
Had 2 slices so I could taste one with red sauce and one white pie slice. The red one was a plain slice loaded with sauce and cheese and I needed two hands to lift it, fold it and shove it in my...
Mike R.
3/31/2025
Heading to a movie nearby, so checked out Freddie & Pepper's, a narrow pizzeria for slices you need to step down to. There's limited seating with one cafe table out front. Ordered a plain cheese...
Sasa P.
6/10/2025
We stopped here on the way to Penn station. It's well located to be able to grab a slice on the go and sit in the park nearby, which we did. As you can see from the photo, the pineapple pizza was...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.