AJ L.
8/22/2025
One of my favorite spots on the East End of Long Island to grab a slice or two. There is a big selection of traditional and gourmet slices to get. The gourmet slices are massive and can...
Michelangelo Pizzeria
$
Closed
(99)
Photos
10095 Main Rd
Mattituck, NY 11952
Michelangelo Pizzeria, located in Mattituck, NY, is the original authentic Italian restaurant and pizzeria on the North Fork of Long Island. Known for its extensive variety of specialty pizzas and a diverse dining menu featuring classic Italian dishes, the establishment prides itself on grand portions and consistent quality flavors.
The elegantly renovated dining room offers a relaxing and romantic atmosphere, perfect for any occasion, from intimate dates to family gatherings. Guests can enhance their meals with a selection from the alluring bar and indulge in the renowned Tiramisu, ensuring a delightful dining experience for all.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.099 reviewsMelissa P.
11/5/2025
Sat for dinner in the dining room in the middle of the week and was absolutely blown away by the friendly staff and quality food. Our group all had large meals,, appetizer sampler, salad and it...
Bebin S.
8/29/2025
It was my second time there the first time I was like wow it's pretty good pizza left happy went in again and there was a line we didn't have problem waiting we waited ordered food three slices 1x...
Pollie L.
7/15/2025
Getting too expensive. Ordered a Caesar salad with shrimp and after waiting for a very long time I went up to the counter to pay and was shocked when the girl said $38! 4 shrimp on lettuce with...
Rose A.
6/5/2022
5/4/22 Just back from Florida, we needed to bring in a few things from the local market and have dinner. We chose to go to the Mattituck market and Michaelangelo pizzeria next door. We enjoyed a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.