Mario's Italian Restaurant

Permanently closed
tripadvisor logo

(99)

Call
Website

Photos

212 Main St
East Setauket, NY 11733
+1 (631) 751-8840
http://www.mariossetauket.com
Jack and Gary Tiply are no strangers to Mario's. Having owned the establishment for nearly 30 years, they've reestablished ownership of the beloved Setauket mainstay in 2021. The brothers are joined by lifelong best friend Billie Phillips in a classic reboot of one of the oldest and most notable Italian restaurants on the North Shore. The combination of three successful restaurateurs promises a Mario's that will be better than ever.

Also at this address

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
4.099 reviews
Photo of Companion32522392567
Party room
12/11/2023

Hosted my husband’s 70th birthday party. The celebration was outstanding everyone raved about the f...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of Gary S
Disgusting food that a dog would not eat
7/22/2023

The chicken was inedible and i spit it out, the worse food ive ever had in my life. Avoid going here...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of Lr260763
Has gone downhill
4/9/2023

I don’t know what happened but ever since they reopened and changed owners it’s just not nearly as g...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Domo Sushi
Eating places, Japanese restaurant, Sushi bar

Domo Sushi

151
•
$$
"Food is great here nice town waiter is really friendly and patient taking our Order I don't find that too often when I go for sushi everyone is in a rush but not at Domo. Nice dining space , and..."
photo of Alison B.
Zorba the Greek
Eating places, Greek restaurant

Zorba the Greek

120
•
$$
"I've been going to this place for 10+ years and without a doubt their food is always delicious. On and off I was going to a more local place for me that went out of business and was happy to find..."
photo of Heather B.
Country House
Eating places, American restaurant

Country House

225
•
$$$
"This place is a Gem! My husband and I come here often and love everything about this place. The atmosphere is cozy and warm and inviting. Most importantly the staff and food are out of this..."
United States›New York›East Setauket›Mario's Italian Restaurant

Partial Data by Foursquare.