Mario's Italian Kitchen Incorporated

$
Open
tripadvisor logo

(43)

Call
Website
212 Main St
East Setauket, NY 11733
+1 (631) 751-8663
http://www.mariositalianrestaurantny.com

Mario's Italian Kitchen, a beloved Setauket mainstay, has been revitalized by brothers Jack and Gary Tiply, who bring nearly 30 years of ownership experience to this classic Italian restaurant on the North Shore.

Under the new ownership, Mario's offers a menu featuring fresh pasta, traditional and unique meat and fish dishes, homemade pizza, and a variety of menus for different dining occasions, promising a dining experience that is better than ever.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
4.043 reviews
Photo of Mary Ann P
The early bird that turned into the late owl.
4/23/2023

OMG where do I start. We had visited before, but tonight the experience trumped all others. We arriv...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of PJE72
Excellent for Reasonably Priced Lunch
10/10/2018

Haven't been to Mario's for dinner in quite a while, but as a neighborhood lunch place it is excelle...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of Steve F
They were good for a while, but...
7/9/2018

Between the reduced menu and loss of some very qualified staff, Mario's is no longer on our rotation...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Via Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Via Pizza

78
•
$
"With dozens of local pizza places in the Setauket/Stony Brook/Port Jeff area, I understand options are plentiful... but there's something to be said about Via Pizza being a true, classic Italian..."
photo of Matt K.
Kai Li Chinese Kitchen
Eating places, Chinese restaurant, Carry-out only (except pizza) restaurant

Kai Li Chinese Kitchen

56
•
$
"the pandemic has been rough for a lot of places but kai li totally revamped their entrance and interior. there's a huge protective screen and contactless ordering, credit card payments are done..."
photo of Serena W.
Italian restaurant

Elaine’s

Elaine's is a charming eatery located in East Setauket, NY, known for its warm ambiance and inviting atmosphere. Offering a diverse menu that features both classic and contemporary dishes, the restaurant caters to a variety of tastes. With friendly service and a cozy setting, Elaine's is the perfect spot for a casual meal or a special gathering with friends and family. Generated from this place's information
United States›New York›East Setauket›Mario's Italian Kitchen Incorporated