Ernie F.
2/18/2021
With many years of living in PV including the Hudson Valley, you can't go wrong with Four Bros. The pizza speaks for itself, unique, Greek taste, and wonderful crust. We've been doing takeout...
Four Brothers Pizza
$$
Closed
(61)
Photos
1890 Route 44
Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
The year was 1976. It was the collaboration of the four brothers that gave way to the name Four Brothers Pizza Inn and its continuing success. During that same year, the famous Greek salad dressing recipe was formulated. Since then the brothers expanded their portfolio of restaurants to 9 Four Brothers while adding The Boathouse in Lakeville, CT. The family uses their local farm to supply the restaurants with certain dairy products and their olive orchards in Greece for olive oil. Today, people throughout New England have discovered from personal experience that the best pizza and salads, among other delicious menu items, is to be found at your local Four Brothers location.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.061 reviews
Tatyanna Y.
8/30/2025
Never been to the area, decided to go here and the waitress older women was so short with us and just gave the impression as if we were bothering her and I did not like that.. it was a nice place...
Russell J.
10/12/2024
First rate experience here. Stopped in for lunch with friends. We sat on the patio, which was lovely. Ordered Carbonara and a pizza. Probably some of the best versions of both dishes I've ever...
Wyrddy R.
6/28/2025
My family has been going to Four Brothers Pleasant Valley since they opened years ago. It was always our "go to" place. NO MORE We all loved their fried chicken. So for the second time we went to...
Katherine S.
8/1/2025
We order gluten free pizza from here and it was not gluten free. I have been sick for three days. please if you are celiac or just gf please be careful.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.