S. S.
12/23/2020
One of the better locally owned pizza's in the area as they use fresher ingredients then most. The cheese is really thick and chewy. The lines can get long on a Friday evening and no room to...
Madison's Pizza Cafe
$
Closed
(63)
Photos
17 North Ave
Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Madison's Pizza Cafe is a pizza restaurant located in Pleasant Valley, NY, offering a diverse menu featuring pizzas, sandwiches, and classic Italian dishes. They provide options for dine-in, takeout, and all-day delivery to meet the needs of their customers.
In addition to their regular menu, Madison's Pizza Cafe also offers catering services for events and special occasions, as well as children's pizza parties. Their goal is to use the best ingredients to create delicious meals for their patrons.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.563 reviewsDonna B.
9/9/2025
Ordered the Six Chicken Strips. Received 4 & 1/2 with a few burnt pieces that the restaurant felt was an acceptable replacement for the 6
C D.
12/23/2024
Once in a while we try this place again while we're in the area. NOPE. Every single time, they upcharge for toppings and ingredients that they just "forget". I don't know if it's laziness,...
Z C.
3/26/2025
Places an order and asked if they could substitute meat instead of cheese for an item, they said yes they could. When the order arrived it was drowned in sauce and cheese, there was no beef but...
Tom C.
8/28/2024
The food was decent the pizza was pretty oily but the crest was good! The chicken parm was good and the staff was nice but im giving it only 3 stars because that girl lauren doesn't spit on it...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.