Susan G.
8/2/2025
Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche, sea bass and blue fish paté!
Amagansett Seafood Store
$$$
Closed
(48)
Photos
517 Montauk Hwy
Amagansett, NY 11930
Amagansett Seafood Store in Amagansett, NY, is a versatile establishment offering a seafood market, seafood restaurant, seafood store, fish restaurant, and catering services.
Known for its fresh and high-quality seafood offerings, Amagansett Seafood Store provides a one-stop destination for seafood lovers in the area, whether they are looking to dine in, purchase fresh seafood to cook at home, or cater an event.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.548 reviewsJames W.
6/22/2025
Perhaps you've sampled the rest, but Mike's Amagansett Seafood is clearly the best. Yes there are cheaper... but none I've ever encountered sells fish and seafood as fresh as what Mike offers....
Noreen W.
5/17/2023
Absolutely the BEST! No reason to make Reservations ever again! Come and Dine with Mike! So Thankful we crossed paths! Coming by everyday whole we're in town!
Lucky B.
1/3/2024
Knowing Mike since like when he first started in Gansettland I find these reviews hilarious , the tequila shot seems to impress some, others not so much , oh well takes all to make a village ha ha...
Elizabeth L.
10/2/2022
Tried this place for the first time a few months ago and when I went back to the area, I had to go back. It is hands down the best lobster roll in the world. So much lobster meat!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.