David S.
9/1/2025
Excellent seafood at fair prices. Good service and rough-but-clean shop. We return frequently.
The Seafood Shop
$$
Open
(73)
Photos
356 Montauk Hwy
Wainscott, NY 11975
Dear Friends,
We are a unique, exciting and atypical catering co.The vibrant scene and rich history of The Seafood Shop are the building blocks for our catering co. and we bring our onsite integrity and good stewardship to our off site events...
Also at this address
Reviews
4.073 reviews
Claudia B.
6/6/2022
On our little sojourn to the Hamptons with so many places still shut down for the last of winter, we were fortunate enough to have this place open and available for us to get lunch. Good thing...
Lilian S.
3/25/2023
The Seafood Shop is a very small shop (only 10 minutes away from Wolffer Estate Vineyard), offering THE BESTTTTT OYSTERS we've everrrrr tasted in a long while! We got half a dozen of their...
Jessica L.
6/19/2024
Ok food but do not go here if you don't want to run the risk of a very poor experience waiting for your food. Our 2-person order took 50 minutes. Given many other customers got food during this...
Mercedes C.
6/28/2020
Whenever hubs and I visit coastal towns, I make it my goal to find Lobster Rolls. Not any mayo-drenched Rolls....only buttered Lobsters Rolls. Seafood Shop came up not far from Sagaponack....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.