Brandon L.
9/13/2025
Local mom & pop shop with amazing bagels! Service is always friendly and amazing. They now have an app to make orders easy and stress free. I highly recommend the bagel sandwiches or just even...
Silver Bay Bagels
$
Closed
(103)
Photos
1831 Hooper Ave
Toms River, NJ 08753
Silver Bay Bagels in Toms River NJ is a premier bagel shop serving delicious breakfast and lunch options. Enjoy our renowned pork roll egg and cheese, fresh lox bagels, and the popular French toast bagel. Our commitment to fresh ingredients and friendly service sets us apart, making every visit a delightful experience. With a lively atmosphere and a cozy seating area, Silver Bay Bagels is perfect for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a meal with friends, you'll love the warm community vibe at our beloved bagel shop. Visit us today for the best bagels in town!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0103 reviews
Erica C.
7/21/2025
4.5 Solid bagel- solid spreads. Easy order and pay online, quick service, large signs for location. Employees were very nice, open inside and clean. Purchased a bakers dozen with three...
Denise Z.
7/5/2025
As my Yelp friends all know, my husband loves a good bagel! He had the everything bagel lightly toasted with veggie cream cheese. He loved it so much I had to hear how we have to go back for days....
Abigail D.
11/2/2025
Ok really... this is disappointing and pathetic for a Jersey bagel. 2 bites and your done, these are flagels not bagels.
Jill M.
11/12/2025
This is my bagel shop of choice. I always get an everything bagel and veggie cream cheese, but my family will branch out into other breakfast items. I don't eat eggs, but my brother's cheese...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.