Tiffany B.
6/24/2024
I'm really surprised at all of these negative reviews. I have always had a good experience. This is my and my friend's go to spot in Long Island to grab bagels. They get orders out quickly and the...
Stuff-A Bagel
$
Closed
(58)
Photos
348 Broadway
Bethpage, NY 11714
Stuff a Bagel in Oyster Bay, Town of, NY is a popular bagel shop conveniently located at 350 Broadway in Bethpage. Whether you arrive by car or train, this cozy eatery is easily accessible, offering a wide variety of delicious bagels and daily specials.
With ample parking available in the back and just a short walk from the Long Island Rail Road LIRR Bethpage Station, Stuff a Bagel is a go-to destination for bagel lovers seeking a satisfying breakfast or lunch option in the area.
Generated from the website
Reviews
2.058 reviews
William G B.
2/7/2025
Yes its loud at times and yes you do wait a little bit for a toasted bagel but the food is always hot fresh and on point.
Craig S.
8/30/2025
I am really not one to post something but I had to post this. I ordered some bagels with cream cheese and noticed there was an extra .15 charge for one of the bagels. Out of curiosity I had to ask...
Amanda I.
5/27/2024
If you want an omelet with black avocado and the cheese on top, this is your place! Anyone who thinks putting an avocado that looks like this on food, should not work in the restaurant business....
Nancy H.
6/5/2023
Frustrating cause they make a good bagel - but they don't make a good sandwich or have nice customer service. There is no consistency with how much cream cheese, meat, salad, whatever filling they...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.