Cindy C.
9/15/2024
First time here! Love the vegan options! I had the vegan banana- oreo ice cream! So good! Took some of the pumpkin ice cream home. Will return! Wonderful and friendly young staff member,...
Nicholas Creamery
$
Open
(53)
Photos
586 River Rd
Fair Haven, NJ 07704
Nicholas Creamery was born out of Nicholas Harary's love for all natural, high quality ingredients, handcrafted recipes, and a desire to take something we all know and love and bring it back to its purest form. We're handmaking small batch ice cream using natural dairy and working directly with local farmers and food artisans to source the freshest, seasonal ingredients.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.053 reviewsThan O.
10/14/2025
When it comes to creative flavors and taste Nicholas Creamery is great. Unfortunately, when we go, there is often a disappointment. The flavors in question frequently do not have much of the...
Yvonne C.
9/18/2022
Yummm y yummmm yumm yummmm!!! Light, tasty and refreshingly whole ice cream!! This spot was clean, open and inviting!! We ordered the toasted coconut - and the Oreo milk shakes!! Very good...
A H.
11/17/2020
Let me start this review by saying the following: It really sucks that I live a little over an hour away from this place, otherwise I would be eating their ice cream every day. They Hudson Coffee...
Albert K.
5/29/2022
Delicious cookies and cream ice cream. Not too thick, nor sweet. They have the ice cream flavors and texture nailed down. Great choices of toppings to choose from.
See a problem?
