Stopping by for a slice with the kids after a swim meet, we were all pleasantly surprised by the quality of their plain slice (or, as they call it in other parts of the United States, "cheese...
Mama Maria Pizzeria
(32)
Photos
Mama Maria Pizzeria, located in West Orange, NJ, offers a diverse menu that features an array of pizzas, breakfast items, starters, salads, and subs. Known for their best-selling options like the classic cheese pie and Buffalo wings, the pizzeria caters to a variety of tastes with both traditional and unique flavor combinations.
The pizzeria also provides a selection of calzones, strombolis, and wraps, ensuring there is something for everyone. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, Mama Maria Pizzeria aims to serve delicious meals without the hassle of extra fees, making it a go-to destination for local pizza lovers.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
I'm not sure when they decided to change their process but we had them last year and it was fine. Ordered today and it was AWFUL. There was so so much cheese it was almost inedible. Furthermore,...
I was eating a slice of pizza and had to spit it out because a literal paper clip was in it and it almost pierced my tongue I thought it was a piece of burnt cheese and that is why it was so hard...
When you ask for fresh garlic on your pizza they don't mess around. Fresh mushrooms. Very Very good pizza. A little heavy on the cheese but THAT'S OK. Will definitely order again.
This is one my favorite pizza spots! I always get their eggplant pizza! It's absolutely DELICIOUS! Definitely will keep ordering it from here!
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.






