Cody M.
10/13/2025
Star Tavern is a must try in the North East NJ Area. It's as NJ as Taylor Ham. Pizza is perfectly crisp and consistent. Has an old man bar vibe, while being spotless. Service is always great,...
Star Tavern
$$
Closed
(1,179)
Photos
400 High St
Orange, NJ 07050
The Star Tavern has been a traditional family favorite for delicious, thin crust pizza served hot and lively in an atmosphere humming with over 75 years of neighborhood character. Come try what The New York Times calls "superior" pizza, The Star Ledger claim it the "best thin crust pizza in NJ", and NJ.com declares is "a Jersey pizza shrine".
Also at this address
Reviews
4.01,179 reviews
Jose M.
9/26/2025
Star Tavern is exactly what you would expect of a neighborhood pizza place. Great atmosphere, delicious food, and great service. Sara, our waitress, was awesome, making sure we were well...
Daphne M.
8/26/2025
The fam and I recently ate here and it was a great experience. An ol school pizza shop with community vibes and laid back feel. The food was very good, fresh and shareable portion sizes. We...
Ritesh M.
5/29/2025
Let me qualify this 2 star first by saying it has potential to move up with just one change (below) Parking is plentiful in the lots next to the restaurant. Staff is friendly and the place was...
Russ R.
8/24/2025
***This review is only for the pizza*** This place has been on my radar for a couple of years. It was just not good and did not live up to the hype or things I heard. The pizza was very...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.