Gaines Street Pies

$
Open
yelp logo

(272)

Call
Website

Photos

603 W Gaines St Ste 3
Tallahassee, FL 32304
+1 (850) 765-9275
http://www.gainesstreetpies.com

Gaines Street Pies is the brainchild of two local enthusiasts in Tallahassee, dedicated to crafting exceptional pizzas. With a commitment to quality, they meticulously sourced fresh ingredients, banishing frozen and mass-produced elements from their kitchen. Each menu item, from homemade meatballs to unique flavor fusions, showcases their passion for creating distinctive and delicious pies.

Since its inception, Gaines Street Pies has garnered praise from the community, prompting rapid expansion to two additional locations in the city. The introduction of innovative combinations and a focus on culinary creativity have solidified their reputation as a go-to destination for pizza lovers. Guests are invited to experience the unparalleled taste of a Gaines Street Pie firsthand at any of their welcoming establishments.

Generated from the website content

Also at this address

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0272 reviews
Photo of Bronson E.
Bronson E.
10/21/2025

Delicious pizza! When I'm around Railroad Square and I'm desperately hungry, I go right over to Gaines Street Pies fr.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Tiffany L.
Tiffany L.
10/12/2025

This pizza place surprised me! The pizza was fresh and delicious. As was the GSP salad. It was six of us and we ordered 2-10" pizzas, 1-14" inch pizza, salad and a slice. Soft drinks totaling $75....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Savone J.
Savone J.
11/16/2024

Popped in one night to grab a late night bite. The guy taking our order was super nice and knowledgeable on the menu. When I asked for some recommendations he said for what I mentioned in passing...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Tank G.
Tank G.
11/3/2024

This is a little hole in the wall pizza joint near the Florida A&M campus. There is limited parking available in restaurants private lot. The restaurant offers carry-out or dine-in. They have a...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Karime H.
Karime H.
3/18/2025

Stop by Gaines street Pies for lunch while in Tallahassee. 1st love the theme of this pizza establishment using comic book theme in their decor and for the menu. You order at the cashier and they...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Midtown Pies
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Pies

Midtown Pies

83
•
$$
"Well, this is a simple review on my one slice of pie. We ordered from Midtown Pies earlier in the week for lunch. Everything looked & smelled great. As I said, I just got a slice with 3 toppings:..."
photo of MaryAnne T.
Panera Bread
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Panera Bread

12
•
$
"The service is great, ordering and getting your food are very convenient, the menu is vast and filled with healthy choices, and there's a lot of comfortable seating, including outdoor seating. The..."
photo of Madelon H.
Gaines Street Pies
Bars and lounges, Eating places

Gaines Street Pies

63
•
$
"First time trying Gaines Street Pies, it was a decent time of day on a Sunday for a Calzone and pizza. They came through with some good options. I went with a 10in pepperoni calzone, and 18in..."
photo of Martel W.
United States›Florida›Tallahassee›Gaines Street Pies

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.