MaryAnne T.
11/20/2020
Well, this is a simple review on my one slice of pie. We ordered from Midtown Pies earlier in the week for lunch. Everything looked & smelled great. As I said, I just got a slice with 3 toppings:...
Midtown Pies
$$
Closed
(83)
Photos
1122 Thomasville Rd Ste 4
Tallahassee, FL 32303
Gaines Street Pies, founded by local entrepreneurs Jeremy Matlow and Ryan Smith, is dedicated to crafting the best pizza in Tallahassee by utilizing fresh, high-quality ingredients and innovative recipes. With a commitment to homemade offerings, they have eliminated freezers and microwaves in favor of house-made meatballs, real sliced bacon, and fresh ranch dressing, creating unique flavor combinations that have garnered enthusiastic feedback from the community.
Since their inception, Gaines Street Pies has expanded from their first location to multiple venues across Tallahassee, including a Midtown location and another in the Sixth District. They invite patrons to explore their inventive pizza creations, all while fostering a welcoming atmosphere conducive to gatherings and celebrations.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.583 reviews
Marilu F.
2/26/2023
I found it expensive for what it was. We ordered a large pizza. Added pepperoni, mushrooms, and I forget what else. Ordered some jalapeño poppers, too, while we were at it. Those jalapeño...
John B.
1/19/2025
One of our go-to pizza places in town. Service very friendly and plenty of space. Parking can be challenging when busy. Get the potato salad side and try the buffalo chicken wrap. Derick Sanders...
Robert T.
11/1/2022
The pizza was better than average. The decor was clearly an afterthought. Their Beer bar consisted of 4 tap beers. No public restroom. They were, however, kind enough to let me use the employee...
John W.
3/7/2021
This time was not so great,,, There was soooo much grease on my two slices it made me sick, I came home and was sick for a few hours....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.