Jolene G.
11/9/2025
The pizza is huge. Come hungry for a slice or bring the tribe for the entire pie. It would be a great place to buy from for an office party.
Benny Montanaro's
$
Closed
(11)
Photos
327 Thelma Dr
Casper, WY 82609
Benny Montanaro's, located in Casper, Wyoming, opened its doors in November 2021 and has quickly become a favorite for locals, offering oversized slices and massive 28-inch pizzas. Inspired by the great outdoors and the Italian meaning of Montanaro, which translates to "mountain," Benny's aims to satisfy appetites with creative specialty pizzas and hearty traditional options.
The restaurant features a menu that showcases toppings like Wild Bill Buffalo Chicken and Three Little Pigs, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Benny Montanaro's is dedicated to creating a memorable pizza experience, making sure customers leave satisfied after indulging in their delicious offerings.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.511 reviews
Alfie S.
4/19/2025
The pizza here is great, i am torn about this and maybe should have just made it 3 stars but the pizza is really good. My complaint is that the dine in experience is so poor, we came in Saturday...
Dave P.
7/14/2025
Fantastic place to go. The pizza is awesome and huge and we just really love it a lot. It's got a special flavor to it that other pizza joint just don't have and the atmosphere is great.
Elvis 7.
9/18/2024
A unique Pizza experience in Casper and I look forward to returning. Thank you for all you do
Brad S.
4/21/2023
I had to take a couple of stars away. The last 2 times I've ordered pizza, they barely put any toppings on, so this time, I paid the $5 for extra toppings. It was like the same amount! I don't...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.