Liliana R.
8/28/2025
Amazing buffalo chicken pizza! Also amazing to dip in their delicious ranch I crave it!
Wild Tomato Pizza - Sister Bay
$$
Open
(377)
Photos
10677 N Bay Shore Dr
Sister Bay, WI 54234
Wild Tomato Sister Bay in Sister Bay, WI, is a beloved pizza restaurant that offers a unique dining experience with a focus on community involvement. Known for their creative pizzas and commitment to giving back, they feature a monthly Donation Creation pizza to support local nonprofits.
Under new ownership by Matthew and Karla Sagorac, Wild Tomato continues to serve as a family-friendly establishment with a familiar atmosphere and menu. With a dedication to preserving the traditions of the restaurant, the Sagoracs aim to engage with the community and maintain the restaurant's reputation as a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0377 reviews
Robin H.
8/22/2025
Picked up pizza tonight, it was awesome! D-lux was our favorite but we also enjoyed our mushroom olive pie. Great option for takeout with family visiting! Can't speak to ambience but service for...
Justin M.
8/12/2025
Wild Tomato has two locations in Door County, and we visited the one in Sister Bay--a very popular spot! When we arrived, we were told there would be a 1-hour wait for a table and a 1-hour wait...
Amita G.
6/21/2025
Went here for dinner with a large party of 10 adults and 3 kids. I would not recommend this place for such large group as they don't have place to accommodate everyone at one table. The place was...
Lea C.
6/14/2025
As the goat parade was today, this place was absolutely packed. It's 52° and all they had left was outdoor seating so we did have to sit outside. I do wish they had outdoor heaters! The pizza was...
See a problem?
