PJ C.
9/25/2025
Time for an updated review since we have now been here at least five times since our initial review. After the shock of our first visit our subsequent visits were in the middle of the week when...
Toby's Supper Club
$
Closed
(236)
Photos
3717 S Dutch Mill Rd
Madison, WI 53718
Toby's Supper Club is a welcoming establishment located in Madison, Wisconsin, specializing in dine-in and carry-out meals. Guests can enjoy a delightful dinner experience starting at 5 pm, with reservations available from Monday to Thursday.
The venue provides a casual yet inviting atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for a leisurely meal with friends and family. For those wanting to stay updated on the latest news and offerings, Toby's encourages patrons to follow them on Facebook.
Generated from the website
Find related places
Reviews
3.5236 reviews
Cristin N.
9/24/2025
Bartenders are excellent and they notice everyone and the level of their drinks. Very efficient with a busy bar. Old fashioneds were great. Wait staff take your order then come back to get you...
John F.
1/21/2025
Found this place in a "Supper Clubs of Wisconsin" book. So nice to see an old fashioned (true) Supper Club still operating in the Madison Area. One of maybe a handful. Literally right off the...
Pat D.
4/23/2025
Last night's Supper Club was our second time eating at Toby's. I was surprised to realize I had not written a review after our first visit many years ago. Last night's visit was stellar and far...
Deborah F.
1/22/2025
There's no place quite like Toby's Supper Club in the Madison area. Toby's has the old-school comfy vibe, super friendly service, beyond delicious food (no matter what you order) and a relaxed...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.