Debra P.
9/7/2025
Purchased small cherry and a raspberry pie, excellent taste, filling was superb and crust was nice and tender, the lard I am sure was the key reason. I will never buy a store pie again. These were...
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe
Closed
(3)
Photos
[W1939 - W2099] Kiel Rd
New Holstein, WI 53061
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe is a quaint bakery nestled in the heart of New Holstein, WI. Specializing in freshly baked goods, this charming shop offers a variety of sweet and savory treats to satisfy every craving.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques, Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe prides itself on delivering delicious pastries and breads made with care and attention to detail. Whether you're in the mood for a flaky croissant or a decadent slice of cake, this local gem has something for everyone to enjoy.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.53 reviews
John F.
8/17/2024
Family owned and run Amish bakery. Only open on Friday and Saturday.... But so worth it! Located on a farm, this little shop has all types of fresh baked goodies. Donuts (of course), pies,...
Steven T.
6/29/2019
I came across this fantastic looking table of baked goods at the Fond Du Lac farmers market while having breakfast in the middle of the market, not in the market but in a restaurant. I don't...
See a problem?
