Jonny P.
9/4/2018
Pizza and lemonade, my two favorite things in this whole world. I can't get over how great this place is, their staff is great and they are super quick with orders. This isn't your typical one and...
Timber Creek Pizza
$$
Closed
(40)
Photos
134 E Lake St
Lake Mills, WI 53551
Timber Creek Pizza Co. in Lake Mills, WI, has been a local favorite since its establishment in 2004, offering a diverse menu of pizzas and subs. Customers rave about the well-balanced flavors of the pizzas, which boast just the right amount of cheese and toppings, catering even to those who typically prefer thicker crusts.
Aside from pizzas, the restaurant also offers a variety of hearty sandwiches and wraps for health-conscious diners, ensuring everyone finds something to enjoy. Timber Creek Pizza prides itself on using fresh, quality ingredients in all their made-to-order dishes, providing a satisfying dining experience for visitors.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
3.040 reviews
Miranda A.
4/11/2025
Okay. I hate that I have to leave this review... Timber Creek has always been a stand up place. But my recent experiences here have been awful. They just keep getting worse too! The girl I've...
Mallory N.
7/2/2025
Pizza was mid at best. Freezer quality pizza. It took 45 minutes for this pizza. They also gave it off to the wrong table twice. Staff were snotty and rude. Tables were dirty. Soda was flat, water...
Theresa F.
6/27/2025
Ice cream board states $4.29 for single cones. Ordered 2 cones. Price was over $11.00. When we questioned it, we were told that was an old price, and the register has the updated prices. You can...
Deb N.
5/4/2025
New Owner has changed Hawaiian pizza from BBQ sauce to Tomato sauce. Insists its the same as always but its not. Yuck...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.