Lindsay K.
6/18/2025
I came here based on a suggestion for fish fry. The service was prompt and friendly, they were kind to my dog, and the Old Fashioneds were pretty yummy. I came here for a fish fry just after...
The Pickled Herring
$$
Closed
(115)
Photos
19 Front St
Bayfield, WI 54814
The Pickled Herring is a charming establishment located in Bayfield, Wisconsin, showcasing a delightful blend of local flavors and warm hospitality. This unique venue serves as a gathering spot for both locals and visitors, offering a memorable dining experience in a picturesque setting.
With a focus on quality and community, The Pickled Herring embraces the essence of Bayfield, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking an authentic taste of the region. Guests can expect a welcoming atmosphere complemented by a menu that highlights the best of local cuisine.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0115 reviews
Elizabeth S.
5/22/2025
We stopped by for a quick lunch on our first day in Bayfield and we're so glad we did! First and foremost, the service was absolutely incredible. I wish I remembered the name of our server because...
Amber D.
5/18/2025
The Pickled Herring is a really cute spot, it fits the overall age & vibe of Bayfield. It's got huge picture windows facing the lake, so you can watch the boats come & go. Our server was...
Cindy O.
10/17/2025
Decided to stop for lunch and ordered the white fish. Extremely dry and thin. Good Coleslaw and fries, but for $18.99 for three pieces of dried out fish that is ridiculous. Skip this place for...
Steve S.
10/3/2025
We came up for Applefest and tried one of their Apple brats. One of the worst things I've ever tasted. One bite and throw it away.
See a problem?
