My husband and I visited The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg WI for the first time on Wednesday, August 20, 2025 and the experience surpassed our expectations! We enjoyed "custom made" salads...
Joe And Diane Z.
8/21/2025
(4)
My husband and I visited The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg WI for the first time on Wednesday, August 20, 2025 and the experience surpassed our expectations! We enjoyed "custom made" salads...
What could improve? The service The food The menu The atmosphere The decor The food was so salty it was inedible
I ordered the Summer Lobster Pasta. I expected this to be a light dish with chunks of lobster meat. The description mentioned the pasta was tossed in a "light lemon-herb sauce". Instead, it was...
It was very cold, and bartenders loomed very unkempt for a Supper Club. If they want to be a Supper Club I would suggest linen tablecloths and napkins with a candle or flowers on the table. Food...