The New Taste of Italy

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(5)

101 S 2nd St
Silver Lake, WI 53170

Reviews

yelp logo
4.05 reviews
Photo of Greg P.
Greg P.
10/2/2025

I had the Lasagna and my wife had Shrimp Fettuccine. Both dishes were delicious and reasonably priced. Complimentary breadsticks were a plus. Glad to have a good restaurant back again.

Photo of Heather M.
Heather M.
2/8/2025

So glad to have a fantastic restaurant back here! Tried the Artisan Pasta -- so GOOD! It's a dead ringer for the ever so popular pasta that was available when Binantis was open. The bread is...

Terri S.
6/20/2025

The food was very good they even allowed a change of sauce which wasn't originally an option for my pasta dish. I had the shrimp Italiano with garlic sauce . My husband had the chicken florentine....

Tim D.
7/24/2025

Horrible..stay away. Thought I would try something different because I heard good things . I was definitely misinformed

Jasmine C.
7/12/2025

Small dining area but the food is delicious!! I had the lasagna and my friends had the carbonara and a pizza. Everything was super tasty. They serve bread with a marinara sauce. Excellent...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesWisconsinSilver LakeThe New Taste of Italy

Partial Data by Foursquare.