Bob F.
10/15/2025
One of our favorite spots. Everything is good as we have worked our way through the menu. The steaks are amazing, the apps are phenomenal (the German pizza) not gonna attempt to spell it, was...
The Mill Supper Club
$$
Closed
(102)
Photos
4128 State Highway 42 57
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
Offering traditional supper club fare with a German twist. Traditional items including; tender juicy steaks, delicious seafood, savory pasta bowls, and unique sandwiches. Our German entrees offer a taste of a time ago and past traditions including Schnitzel, Sauerbraten, and Beef Rouladen. We also offer Nightly Feature Specials and of course The Mill Famous FamilyStyle Chicken every Sunday. Our unique menu with tastes of modern and traditional American and German cuisine truly offers something to please everyone’s palate. We look forward to serving you!
Reviews
4.0102 reviews
Fred Z.
8/22/2025
Place LOOKED promising from the outside- then went to the "dining" room at 6:45 and it was like a huge cafeteria setting with a tiny salad bar in the middle..... one couple sitting in there!...
Dave L.
5/6/2024
This is a 3.5 review; however, I won't give a 3 star because of Yelp refusing to allow for more accurate ratings. We were visiting Door County and wanted a supper club experience. Depending on...
Robert M.
8/12/2025
I had the Weiner Schnitzel and my wife had the walleye dinner. Both were terrific. The salad bar was nice. We come here once a year. Always very good service. Always very clean and a nice atmosphere.
Gary B.
8/5/2025
My son, his three small children, my wife and I had dinner there recently. My wife and I ordered the rib eye steak dinner. We were very disappointed. Both were under cooked, way too much fat,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.