Declan S.
6/22/2025
Lovely long-standing independent business. The signature ice cream is delicious, and the sandwiches are very good too. Prices extremely reasonable. Fun selection of local cheeses too. Service is...
The Milk Pail
$
Open
(22)
Photos
36 W Marshall St
Rice Lake, WI 54868
The Milk Pail is an old fashioned ice cream parlor that serves 25+ flavors of Wisconsin hand dipped ice cream. That doesn't include our featured flavors. We also have lunch, a coffee bar with beans from a local roaster, and local retail foods available such as cheese, meats, jams, honey, maple syrup and more. Thank you for looking us up, we look forward to seeing you!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.522 reviews
Meagan M.
9/28/2025
I always visit the Milk Pail when I'm visiting or passing through Rice Lake. The place itself is as cute as a button with its true red barn appearance and old time diner feel inside. The staff is...
Tiffany W.
6/11/2024
You cannot go wrong with supporting local nor eating ice cream! While the line can get long (I suspect most visitors in the summer are on summer time anyway or visiting a cabin) so I recommend...
Richard M.
7/5/2025
Stopped in around 4pm on a Saturday and there were a few people in the shop but no line. My wife wanted two scoops of butter brickle but the two young ladies working the counter had a conclave and...
Chris D.
8/2/2023
Great little hometown old school type of ice cream shop. The service was awesome even though the place was packed. A must stop place in Rice Lake!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.