Nikki B.
10/10/2025
I have been passing this place for a few years when i started traveling to Cashton. I have been curious since day one. Always en route w a plan in mind i didnt have time to stop. After seeing a...
The Cotter Pin
$$
Open
(37)
Photos
20671 State Highway 27
Sparta, WI 54656
The Cotter Pin, LLC in Sparta, WI, offers a unique dining experience with a menu featuring pizzas, wings, sandwiches, Paninis, soups, Quesadillas, and wraps. Their urban rustic style and full bar with craft beers and a selection of wines make it a perfect escape just 3 miles south of Sparta in Leon.
With a focus on simplicity and quality, The Cotter Pin prides itself on serving delicious hot sandwiches like the Cotter Pin Reuben and Pulled Pork, as well as creative dishes such as Buffalo Chicken Mac and Cheese and Juusto made from local Amish farms. Guests can enjoy a variety of appetizers, salads, and wings, all in a cozy setting that welcomes visitors to stop in, say hello, and stay for a while.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.537 reviews
Emmanuel C.
6/17/2025
Not a fan of the Cotter Pin. Upon entering there were no greetings or signs to decipher if it's self seating or if a host would arrive. Furthermore there were employees that I made eye contact...
Peter E.
10/7/2025
Their food is so delicious. Great customer service and nice environment. Try the Mac b cheese for sure! Seems an odd choice but it is yummy.
Jenna K.
9/14/2024
Love this place-- Buffalo chicken Mac is bomb, so is the garlic chicken pizza. Friendly staff, cute place
Jasmine F.
9/15/2023
Decided to try this place for the first time a few days ago. The exterior is inviting. The interior decor is updated and clean. The service was great. My big hubby ordered the personal...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.