Tami F.
9/6/2025
We had to stop in before we left DC for two reasons. The amazing cherry deserts and my cat loved the toy we bought her last time. Unfortunately they were out of the toys, but we really enjoyed...
Sweetie Pies
$$$
Closed
(85)
Photos
9106 State Highway 42
Fish Creek, WI 54212
Sweetie Pies in Fish Creek, WI is a local establishment that offers a unique dining experience. With a focus on quality ingredients and delicious flavors, they provide a range of delectable dishes to satisfy any palate.
From their signature pies to savory creations, Sweetie Pies ensures a delightful culinary journey for visitors. With their commitment to excellence, it's no wonder they have become a beloved destination for locals and tourists alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.085 reviewsJenny S.
10/23/2025
I'm a pie lover and stopped to check this store out and was very disappointed. One of the poorer pieces of pie I've ever had!
Paula S.
10/13/2025
Worst pie ever! Was so excited to stop here after getting delicious pies last year, but sooo disappointed this year. Pie was dry, apples were almost a solid mush...couldn't even tell they were...
John F.
9/11/2023
A pie shop is Door County... of course! Yes, you can get pies at lots of places in this tourist destination. But you will not get the assortment of choices that this place has. Plus they are...
B G.
9/5/2024
Best cherry pie. This is the first time I've eaten cherry pie without the gel. It's all cherries and the crust isn't too thick. If you're looking to purchase a whole pie please know that you have...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.