Thien-Tyler N.
11/8/2025
Food 5/5 Service 4/5 Ambiance 4.5/5 One of the stars of the Milwaukee Public Market, the St. Paul Fish Company sells amazing, fresh seafood that's sure to be used in a wide variety of foods....
St Paul Fish Company
$$
Closed
(1,497)
Photos
400 N Water St
Milwaukee, WI 53202
Located inside the Milwaukee Public Market in Downtown Milwaukee, St. Paul Fish Co. offers the freshest seafood in Wisconsin. Pick up a wide variety of fresh fish to prepare at home or enjoy the extensive menu at the oyster bar, in the full service dining room, or grab a drink along with your meal at the outdoor tiki bar. Consistently voted the best seafood restaurant in Milwaukee!
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.51,497 reviews
Jonathan S.
11/1/2025
Always a solid choice when I'm craving seafood. I usually get the lobster roll and my spouse the lobster boil, both are excellent! The lobster is always fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked....
Sayaka Y.
10/20/2025
Super fresh seafood and a friendly service. It's in the food market but they had a good amount t of seating. Lobster roll have a lot of loster meat in it. Shrimp cocktail was super fresh and no...
Enna J.
11/1/2025
crowded dining space within Public Market but the food is really good. Reasonable prices and super friendly service.
Andrea U.
9/16/2025
We saw the oyster bar and we were told that we can come inside and get a table inside or outside for two. After reading the reviews, I was amazed we were able to come in and snag a table. Joe,...
See a problem?
