Natalie S.
4/19/2024
Sally knocked our wedding cakes out of the park! I searched throughout the greater Milwaukee area for someone that could execute a banana cake, that had the flavor/texture we were looking for and...
Sally's Sweet Shoppe
$$
Open
(31)
Photos
S42W31370 State Road 83
Genesee Depot, WI 53127
A small batch, from scratch little bakery in the heart of historic Genesee Depot. We start each day fresh with breakfast pastries, 3-4 different breads, cookies, bars, cupcakes, desserts, candies, and we also make celebration cakes & cookie cakes!
Reviews
4.531 reviews
Gabe W.
2/6/2023
Wide selection of products and they look sinfully delicious, they take special orders for cakes or anything that you might want, however, their frosting is to sweet for my tastes and to much...
Jean T.
9/15/2024
Beautiful work. I needed a 1/2 sheet cake with less than a weeks' notice. I ordered the marble with butter cream frosting. Went with simple pastel flowers and happy 100th . The cake was moist,...
Jan P.
4/25/2024
Desserts are all homemade and delicious. Some new ones often but always the same yummy ones consistently. The gluten free bars are amazing! The service is excellent!
Nicole V.
5/21/2023
Phenomenal sweets. Absolutely delicious, staff was super sweet. Shop is totally cute. I would highly recommend.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.