Ryan M.
11/6/2024
Super friendly and knowledgeable staff. Fantastic prices for vintage toys in all conditions. Be sure to ask about items you can't find, they have extra storage in back that may have what you need....
Replay Toys
Closed
(4)
Photos
104 E Wisconsin Ave
Appleton, WI 54911
Replay Toys is a unique toy store located in Appleton, WI, offering a diverse selection of toys and collectibles for enthusiasts of all ages. Visitors can explore a vast table brimming with bulk LEGO pieces, alongside an array of mini-figures, including popular franchises like Star Wars, G.I. Joe, Transformers, and more.
Specializing in nostalgic toys, Replay Toys also caters to fans of classic series such as He-Man, Power Rangers, Star Trek, as well as die-cast car collectors with offerings from Hot Wheels and Matchbox. Model train aficionados and Littlest Pet Shop fans can also find treasures to add to their collections.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
4.54 reviewsChristian G.
5/11/2024
I absolutely love Replay Toys. The owner is very friendly and helpful. Top notch service. They have a wide selection of vintage action figures, mostly from the 1990s and 2000s, but also action...
Kao V.
12/1/2019
If you're looking for vintage toys, this is definitely the place to be. Collectors? Not so much. It's still a fun nostalgic place to visit. The shop is quite disorganized so if you are looking...
Jess L.
4/23/2021
I love going to this store and picking through their giant LEGO table to find pieces missing from sets, or fun pieces, etc. They also have lots of other toys, including vintage things from my...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.