Jill B.
10/21/2025
I became a fan of Poppy Bakery at the Brookfield Farmer's Market, and now I try to make the trek to the east side bakery whenever I can to score some goodies! The service is always excellent,...
Poppy Bakery
Closed
(16)
Photos
2021 E Ivanhoe Pl
Milwaukee, WI 53202
Poppy Bakery is a small-batch bakery located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, dedicated to quality and seasonality in their offerings. They emphasize nostalgic flavors by utilizing local ingredients whenever possible.
In addition to their regular menu, Poppy Bakery provides catering options and encourages customers to preorder items such as brownies and cookies for special events. Their commitment to handcrafted pastries ensures a unique and delightful experience for all who visit.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
5.016 reviews
Scott W.
10/13/2025
First time here. Have been wanting to come since they opened and were reviewed in the paper. Came on a Sunday morning before noon, and there was a line pretty much out the door. It didn't take...
Ellie B.
7/8/2025
The baked goods at this bakery are so good, I kind of don't even know why I bake myself. I had a perfect chocolate chip cookie, a perfect chocolate brownie with sea salt and that's really all you...
Lico J.
6/14/2025
Loved the lineup of baked goods here! Everything was beautiful, creative, and truly unique for Milwaukee. If it's in Chicago there would be a line haha. My picky toddler loved the miso chocolate...
Pallavi S.
7/7/2025
Love when new spots open up in Milwaukee and I was so glad a friend asked me to check out Poppy Bakery with her! Everything was so good and flavorful and felt homemade. I loved the open kitchen...
See a problem?
