Judy H.
6/24/2025
This was my first visit and I was very pleased!! The staff were really nice and friendly!! The inside of the restaurant was very cute and clean!! I had the Jr veggie pizza and I must say it was...
Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(42)
Photos
224 W Cottage Grove Rd
Cottage Grove, WI 53527
Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria, located in Cottage Grove, WI, has been serving up delicious pizza, calzones, pasta, subs, salads, and more since 2007.
With a wide variety of menu options and daily lunch specials, Papa Jimmy's is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike looking for a satisfying meal in the area.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.542 reviewsJeremy B.
6/21/2025
My daughter and I stopped here on our way home from UW Madison campus tour. My daughter found Papa Jimmy's via an internet search. What a find!! The hostess was very pleasant and welcoming she...
King J.
6/5/2025
Pizza was spectacular. I got a 16in pepperoni and a jr margarita with cheese curds. Service was great, very friendly people. Love the drive thru feature. The food was amazing, 10/10 I do recommend.
Aurora A.
11/14/2022
Ordered a large Hawaiian pizza here on a Saturday night with a Bucky book coupon. Order was completed very fast for a Saturday night and drive through was convenient for picking up! Drive through...
Carmen M.
6/4/2021
Had no idea they had a drive through! I ate in and had a fantastic turkey sub for a very reasonable $6. The bread and seasoning made it extra delicious! Fast polite service and clean interior.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.