M L.
9/5/2025
Absolutely An Amazing Experience! Delicious fish dinner and cherry pie to top it off! Make your reservation well in advance! A must when in town!
Old Post Office Restaurant
$$
Closed
(277)
Photos
10040 Water St
Sister Bay, WI 54234
Old Post Office Restaurant, nestled in Sister Bay, WI, offers a unique dining experience with historical charm. Since 1874, this waterfront establishment has been serving up delicious meals, including their renowned traditional Door County Fish Boil.
Guests can enjoy the captivating view from the front patio, adding to the ambiance of the dining experience. The restaurant's rich history is evident in its decor, providing a glimpse into the past while savoring a meal.
From informative and entertaining fish boils to scrumptious breakfast options, Old Post Office Restaurant caters to both locals and travelers seeking a taste of authentic Door County cuisine. Whether dining indoors or outdoors, visitors can immerse themselves in a culinary tradition that has stood the test of time.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5277 reviews
Wanda H.
8/9/2025
Came for the experience of the Fish Boil. The food was good, though not great. But I'm not sure how you're supposed to add more flavor when you're boiling. The ambiance was a bit lacking as...
Jeff P.
9/7/2024
Ephraim is one of the prettiest and most historical locations in door county and this little gem is right on the waterfront in the harbor. Good location great service outstanding views make the...
Sherry W.
7/15/2024
We called Monday morning for a same day reservation for two People in July. We showed up at 4:30 for the fish boil demonstration outside and then dined at 5pm. You have a choice of indoor or...
Marsha S.
7/20/2025
First they show you how they make it, afterwards you get a full meal (fish or ribs or chicken with salad , bread and for desert cherry pie and we ate outside while watching the sun set - it was...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.